Why You Shouldn’t Value Your Music Based On Its Popularity

One of the biggest transformations music has undergone over the past two decades is the ability to see songs rack up views, streams, and downloads in real time. Local and national charts still gauge an artist’s radio performance and album sales, but detailed metrics offered by music platforms now let listeners see how much a song is being listened to practically in real time. But public song stats are a small fraction of the detailed analytical information most artists now have access to when it comes to who is listening to their music.

From a music business perspective, having loads of perpetually updating fan analytics at your fingertips is helpful, but I think there’s also a downside to consider. Numbers can’t tell the whole story of worth behind an artist’s music. Since most music is now digitized in some form, it means that the majority of music consumption can be measured. It’s human nature to want to assign value and meaning to the songs that generate the most stats, but there’s a whole bunch of problems to consider if you think that your music is only good if it’s popular.

Why all good music doesn’t necessarily find an audience in 2019

An unfathomable amount of new music comes out each day, and some of it is very good. Whether it comes from a successful artist with bottomless resources at their disposal, or a teenaged bedroom producer sharing their work for the first time, the current musical climate is uber favorable when it comes to letting just about anyone distribute and sell their music online. This means that anytime you release new music, you’re competing with tens of thousands of other artists. Good music doesn’t get heard because more songs come out each day than fans can possibly listen to. And while digital music platforms have built-in tools to help connect new music with listeners, there’s simply not enough resources to put every released song in front of a listener.

Musical value can’t be measured in stats

If you’re one of the many musicians discouraged by how little your music is being listened to, it’s important to step back and assess the way you value music. Metrics like streams and downloads are important, but they won’t give you the entire picture of value when it comes to your music. What makes music valuable completely depends on the individual, but things like creativity, craftsmanship, and personal meaning are important to consider. Set aside the part of your human nature that wants to value things through the numbers and dig deeper into what you really love about about music. If you find that what you’re creating embodies what resonates with you about another artist’s music, then your work has value no matter how much it’s being listened to.

Get unbiased fan feedback on your songwriting, production, and more with brand new Crowd Reviews

There’s nothing wrong with wanting to find an audience for your music, but purely basing your work’s worth off of its popularity is unhealthy and can stymie a promising musician’s career. Look past the numbers, and you’ll find that determining a song’s real value is a lot harder than you might think. When everything superficial gets stripped away, the last and most important judge of whether your music has value or not is you.

Patrick McGuire is a writer, musician, and human man. He lives nowhere in particular, creates music under the name Straight White Teeth, and has a great affinity for dogs and putting his hands in his pockets.

AgniWhy You Shouldn’t Value Your Music Based On Its Popularity


Join the conversation
  • Chuck Sadosky - June 4, 2019 reply

    Today this message is needed more than ever, more than even yesterday.

  • Tim - June 6, 2019 reply

    Hey Patrick! The timeliness of this article is uncanny. Thanks so much!

  • Mark - June 6, 2019 reply

    Honestly totally disagree. People can always write and record their own music for themselves, friends and families entertainment and enjoyment. People have been doing that since tape recorders became affordable in the 1960’s. Nothing new.
    It’s called a “hobby”. If all you want is a hobby, then don’t worry about anything.
    But if you want to be “in” the music industry, then you need to reach new fans every day. And this little article totally ignores that. You have to go out and get your music “heard” and build your numbers along with your popularity. And you need to market your music and yourself to strangers in order to build an audience. It is hard work – it don’t come easy.
    Otherwise, you are not in the music industry. – you have a hobby.

  • Bix - June 8, 2019 reply

    Good article!

  • Sheila Danelle Wonders - July 23, 2019 reply

    Dear Mark, You may not be in agreement with this, “little article”. But the idea that you alone can value your work is good news to those wondering, “Am I a hobbyist or a player?” That is not your decision to make for the lot of us. It’s our choice. Do not belittle the well intended, please. It’s game over for the Monday morning quarterbacks. Not everyone that hold a paintbrush is an artist but that is their decision to make. Good day to you sir.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *