Why You Should Finish Every Song You Start

If you’re an active songwriter, it’s safe to assume you have a lot of unfinished ideas rolling around inside your brain taking up space on your hard drives. We think if we write a ton of music, we’ll eventually stumble on a couple ideas that are really good, and this is true. However, there’s one important caveat that often gets left out of this conversation. Without transforming your ideas into finished songs, you’ll make it harder to write your best music and reach your full potential as a songwriter.

Why it’s worth it to finish all your ideas––even the bad ones

Songwriting isn’t a pursuit for the faint of heart, but you already knew that. It can be grueling, thankless, and frustrating. If you want to succeed in this game, you’ll need to cultivate lots of resilience and discipline, the sort of willpower that keeps you working when you don’t want to. A major part of this gritty approach to writing music is finishing what you start. It’s easy to begin songs and often hard to complete them. Following through builds your experience as a songwriter and allows you to hear a song in its entirety, and there’s a lot of value in this. 

Random beats, song lyrics, chord progressions, synth riffs, and bass lines don’t carry the same musical and creative currency that an entire demo does. Midway through a song, you might decide that you don’t like what you’re working on, or that you’re simply not inspired enough to follow through. But if you make the effort to finish what you’re working on, you’ll have the satisfaction of knowing and hearing how everything in the music you’re working on ties together, develops, and resolves. In the worst-case scenario, doing this is helpful for your songwriting experience and work ethic. But in the best case, the idea you weren’t sure of midway through its development might actually be a great song.

Your perception of your unfinished songs might be wrong 

One of the best reasons to finish all of your songs is because you might have some promising music on your hands and not even know it. Some ideas are just plain bad. We all know that. But other ideas could be incredible with a little development and tweaking. This is why finishing what you start is so important. We often think we know the entire story behind a song before we’re done writing it, and that’s just not true. At any given time, there are endless creative paths we can take with our music. By refusing to give up on a song, you give it the chance it needs to develop into something unique and profound. 

When it’s time to spread the word about your music, it’s time to look at Promote It

What it means to “finish” a song

The process of finishing a song for you could include a professional recording, production, and mastering. Or, on the other side of the coin, it could be as basic as recording a quick demo on your smartphone. There are no rules for transforming vague ideas into completed music other than assigning a set structure and flow to a song. You’ll need a chord progression and some sort of melody most likely at the very least. This is different from creating random parts of music that don’t tie together. What makes an idea “completed” more or less is cohesion. While it takes work to finish songs, it doesn’t have to be anything like the process of recording a song for an album. You can think of bare bones recordings of your songs as demos, and having lots of them is a huge asset for a serious songwriter. The major benefit to having lots of them recorded and easy to access is being able to have lots of choices to mull over when it comes time to pick songs for a new album. Developing the discipline and follow-through you need to complete songs now will pay off throughout your music career in huge ways.

Write as often as you can, and finish what you start. If you build a songwriting practice that allows for these things to happen, you’ll be on your way to meeting your creative potential as a songwriter. 

Patrick McGuire is a writer, musician, and human man. He lives nowhere in particular, creates music under the name Straight White Teeth, and has a great affinity for dogs and putting his hands in his pockets.

RebeccaWhy You Should Finish Every Song You Start


Join the conversation
  • Steven Neal Wagner - August 18, 2021 reply

    Great message, Patrick.

    It’s also important to finish the ideas you start because it gets you into the habit of finishing. I have dozens, if not hundreds of song beginnings – titles, lines, verses, etc.

    During the middle of 2020 I said I go to write 100 songs in 100 weeks. Much of my intention was to finish all the ideas that I had started and put aside. But I also wrote things from the ground up and finish them in one week. I ended up only going 16 weeks and getting 11 or 12 songs that I was really happy with. The others were kind of Suckville, but I had persisted and gotten a song.

    I’d say that a not-so-good finished song is better than an OK idea.

  • Dave Grandel - August 21, 2021 reply

    An easy way to finish those “lost songs”, the “two line ideas”, the “great title, now what do I do with it”, “Man, what a killer riff!”, etc., is to co-write! Get involved with a songwriting group (I belong to several Facebook groups, a local “in-person” one, as well as an online community called “100 Days Of Songwriting”. Their doors are now open to new members but once the 100 Days starts, they are closed again. I have made many good music friends in there and have co-written with a bunch of folks I would never have met without it! In fact, the article that I am replying to linked to by a 100 Days member!

    Back on track now, I’m more convinced to finish what I start, my problem is finding the time. We are all pressed for time, I know, but it just seems exactly like the prophet Jim (Croce) foretold…

    “…but there never seems to be enough time to do the things you want to do, once you find them…”

    For those of you who don’t know these words, read and re-read them and try to put them into a rhythm that fits your musical sensibilities and THEN go listen to “Time In A Bottle” to how they are sung. I read them as I typed and without the music I know for them, I could not imagine what the phrasing might be…
    We are truly blessed to be creators…finish what you start.

  • Cosmo key - August 23, 2021 reply

    Coming back to an old project after a couple of months time seems to help me well. Sometimes you just cant bring certain elements into a song from the start. But if you refresh your brain with a couple months time, or even a couple of weeks or so, that seems to be the magic ingredient sometimes. I have a few finished songs that started with an idea I had originally planned to delete. Seeing how those tracks turned out is a great reminder of why you shouldn’t give up on any of the songs you are working on. Thank you for the great post.

  • Anna M. - September 3, 2021 reply

    I used to never be able to finish a song and now, I don’t scrap anything anymore.

    Basically, if a song is going in a direction that makes me not like it anymore, I simply tweak it until I do like it. It may be vastly different from what I start out with, but technically it’s still the “same song” yeh?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.